sales and relationship building resume
writing term papers college
dissertation masters finance
master thesis sports facility survey
phd thesis in international marketing
presales resume
accounting dissertation
writing master thesis methodology
environmental service aide resume
francis bacon essays
college essay about violin
resume for director of sales
literature review on performance related pay
essay about love money
shooting an elephant and other essays
database design for business applications dissertation
thesis on cash flow budget
government purchase card holder resume
b2b sales experience resume
essay on the suffragettes
essay logical order
sales executive responsibilities resume
art therapy masters thesis
descriptive essay with spatial order
cover letter for retail sales manager
essay writing about friends
purchase clerk resume
sales and marketing cover letter
dissertation internet banking
gender identity disorder research paper
swot analysis essay
essay on science in service of humanity
thesis on sula
cover letter of sales representative
essays on things fall apart
master thesis corporate governance
cover letter for customer service and receptionist
astronomy homework help online
writing an essay about a friend
good attention getter for college essay
personal narrative essay
ksa essay writers
sales catering coordinator resume
cover letter for comcast customer service
proofreading
inventory related sales system thesis
phd thesis composite material
cover letter for social services position
essay about zoo visit
distance learning business plan
insurance sales manager resume india
essay about helpful personality
sales training cover letter
professional resume writer barrie ontario
reflective essay on creative writing
direct sales on resume
narrative argument essay
timed essay prompts
cloning essay
research paper on divorce
cause and effect essay on exercise
master thesis embedded systems
gm foods essay
essay about life and nature
software as a service research paper
natural order macbeth essay
research papers on effective communication with customers
phd thesis consumerism
essay on target corporation
dental nursing coursework help
multi paragraph essay
driver sales representative resume
how to write a 5 paragraph essay
essay about helping the less fortunate essays
50 essays samuel cohen
pharmaceutical customer service associate cover letter
life changing event essay
georgetown sfs admissions essay
high school student resume for college admission
dissertation proposal presentation powerpoint
car sales trainee cover letter
international trade papers
latex phd thesis
help writing teacher cover letter
director creative services resume
master thesis flow cytometry
essay about life in korea
resume for transportation sales
matthew parkinson phd thesis
how to narrow expository essay gas and oil prices
essay on globalization
essay about family issues
resume for sales representative retail
sales rep cover letter resume
master thesis finance banking
how to write an application letter and resume
distinctive voices essay martin luther king
cover letter customer service associate
radio sales assistant cover letter
numerical analysis homework help
phd thesis theology
master thesis bridges
insurance customer service agent resume
what is reverse chronological order of a resume
how to write an application letter to get a job
phd thesis capital structure
hospitality sales coordinator resume
review of literature on customer satisfaction in life insurance
essay on the great depression
legal research and writing services
deforestation research paper
reflective essay about group work
life changing experiences essay
subway business plan help
graduate school admission essay nursing
ap computer science homework help
essay about family roles
write a college essay about yourself
help paragraph writing
services coordinator resume
americanism essay contest
eosinophils gm food
essay about myself 150 words
primary homework help volcanoes
cover letter for phd in molecular biology
how to write a motivation letter for university admission
cause of divorce essay
best grad school admission essays writing
helping in architecture assignment
essay about virtual friends
single mother essay
painter helper resume
essay about your body
customer service call center cover letter
dissociative identity disorder research paper outline
phd thesis gantt chart
writing an application for job
sales and finance manager resume
thesis theme custom headline meta
claims customer service representative resume
ap literature essay questions
a worn path essay
essay on world without borders
summary of qualifications in customer service for resume
proposal for research
cover letter sales position hotel
sales trading and research cover letter
research papers chocolate
customer food service resume
functionalism and gender inequality
essay about the capital punishment
customer service team lead cover letter
phd thesis on statistical quality control
disney and pixar merger impact on stock
district bank manager resume
glatzel water budget thesis
cv writing service nottingham
do you underline essay titles
phd thesis content management system
custom admission essay on university
how to write an admission essay body paragraph
cover letter retail buyer position
essay on night by elie wiesel
essay about friendship for students
customer service repcall center cover letter
buy thesis recto
personal statement essay for scholarships
dissertation forensic investigation
best online essay editing service
writing essay about friend
zoo animal border writing paper
community service reflection essay
environmental politics phd thesis
distribution assistant cover letter
phd thesis organizational culture
purchase order management resume
resume broadcaster service
good sales resume summary
order resume online papa john39s
white collar crime essay
master thesis on credit risk management
chemical sales resume
outstanding sales cover letter
english help websites
some people think that to get good education one should go abroad essay
divided and undivided thesis statement
world war 1 research paper
essay about video game
SECONDDRAFT.ORG
Home Investigations Al-Durah Reception and Consequences Impact Arab World
Remembering Muhammad Al-Durra

"Remembering Muhammad Al-Durra"
Published: ARAB NEWS, 2005-09-28
Author: Fawaz Turki


ABSTRACT: Author describes al-Dura as a permanent symbol of Israel's opression, and the image of his death carries with it "the emblematic power of a battle flag."

QUOTE: "For in its gruesome starkness, its distinctive dread, that video (and choose here whatever frame you want) jettisons all of the Palestinian conflict's subplots — checkpoints, collective punishment, targeted assassinations, land grabs, home demolitions — and leaves it bare for us all to see."

KEYWORDS: Martyrology, J Paradigm, Palestinian Suffering.


URL: Read source

TWO men shot Muhammad Al-Durra five years ago this week, on Sept 30, 2000, two days after the outbreak of Intifada II: The occupation soldier who shot the fatal bullet that killed him, and the photo journalist who shot the iconic picture that immortalized him.

Muhammad, of course, was the 12-year old boy killed in the arms of his father, who had vainly tried to shield him from harm as both crouched, compressed and trapped, between a low wall and a large metal barrel at the Netzarin Junction.

The harrowing image, filmed by Palestinian cameraman Talal Abu Rahma for France 2 television, carries the emblematic power of a battle flag. Its heart-rending intensity, its fevered veracity, puts it beyond all rational understanding. It is a lasting image of the war against the Palestinian people and how Israel has conducted it.

Hundreds of poems have been written about the boy. Several countries, including Egypt, Tunisia and Belgium, have issued stamps commemorating the event. Parks and streets (including one in Cairo, where, tellingly, the Israeli Embassy is located) have been named in his honor.

Yes, that image has encoded its dark derangement in our consciousness, attesting to how a picture, clichés aside, is worth a thousand words, how we live in a world today where a verbal matrix is not the only one in which the articulation and conduct of the mind's eye are conceivable.

For in its gruesome starkness, its distinctive dread, that video (and choose here whatever frame you want) jettisons all of the Palestinian conflict's subplots — checkpoints, collective punishment, targeted assassinations, land grabs, home demolitions — and leaves it bare for us all to see.

Blow up one of these frames, or put it under a magnifying glass, as I have done, and what strikes you most of all is the blood pooling under the boy's legs, an image more chilling than the depiction of any war scene.

The death of Muhammad was the picture seen around the world because photographs transcend language barriers and are relentlessly direct in the message they strive to convey.

"Ever since cameras were invented in 1839," wrote the late literary critic Susan Sontag in "Regarding the Pain of Others," a follow-up to "On Photography," her earlier book on the subject, "photography has kept company with death."

You stop in your tracks here, till you read on: "Once the camera was emancipated from the tripod, truly portable, and equipped with a range finder and a variety of lenses that permitted unprecedented feats of close observation from a distant vantage point, picture-taking acquired an immediacy and authority greater than any verbal account in conveying the horror of mass-produced death."

Not satisfied with the dictum that a picture is worth a thousand words, Israeli officials and their apologists in the US and elsewhere have turned it upside down to read that a picture is worth a thousand arguments — namely that the boy died in the crossfire at the hands of Palestinian militants, not Israeli soldiers. Humbug!

Since the intifada started, and since that provocative walkabout by Ariel Sharon on the grounds of the Al-Aqsa Mosque that triggered it, five years ago today, the Palestinians — left unable to choose how they lived, only how they died — turned from stone-throwing to suicide-bombing, and the Israelis turned from machine guns to tanks and Apache helicopters.

According to the latest figures put out by the United Nations Childrens' agency, UNICEF, 542 Palestinian children have been killed over the last five years. Children under occupation continue to live mutilated lives, many of them, according to the UN agency, "suffering emotional problems," like speech impediments, bedwetting, crying, panic attacks and temper tantrums, symptoms that manifest themselves in adult life as aggressive behavior.

That picture of 12-year old Muhammad Al-Durra embodies that human devastation. It joins that pantheon of iconic pictures from around the world — the horrific image of the execution of a Vietcong prisoner in a Saigon street by a Vietnamese police officer in 1968; John Filo's shot of a girl wailing over the body of a slain Kent State student in 1970; that shot from Vietnam in 1972 of a little girl running — naked and screaming — from a napalm bombing toward the lens of Nick Ut's camera; and most recently, a hooded Iraqi prisoner standing on a box with wires connected to his hands.

All these pictures, like that depicting the death of Muhammad, are not just iconic, but impactful as well, in the way they both represent a radical transformation of how news is delivered and how, through them, we define our objective reality.

I will conclude with a quote from an unlikely source — Donald Rumsfeld. Yes, none other than the American secretary of defense.

At an angry Senate subcommittee hearing in May, 2004, following the release of those photos of grinning American soldiers humiliating their Iraqi prisoners — photos that inspired moral outrage all over the world — Rumsfeld testified, unwittingly attesting to the power of the craft of photography: "It is the photographs that give one the vivid realization of what actually took place. Words don't do it. ....You see the photographs and you get a sense of it, and you cannot help but be outraged."

At that Netzarine Junction, almost exactly five years ago, the camera did not blink. It did not lie. It recorded reality in a visual way that will be etched in our consciousness for generations to come.

Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 

Banner_VIE_small2

/

Banner_SEE_small2

 

 

animated_banner

Facebook MySpace Twitter Digg Google Bookmarks