mgm grand casino
blackjack basic strategy winning
bingo money
art palace austin
flying sevens super slot machine
taste of home blue chip
play nascar simracing
how to play slots in
how to play live
baccarat gambling
nathan james hippodrome
big win
dubuque iowa
roulette software
casino en
vegas poker
the office casino night
casino windsor
jackpotjoy slots facebook
best hotel casino las vegas
adjusting from online to live
deuces are wild poker
chicago casinos near
security casino
play book of ra
bhangarh ruins palace of
bonus sans depot golden euro
chepauk palace
maryland online poker
5 star casino
foxy casino
carbon poker
carnival of mystery slot
hunan palace papillion
bellagio casino las vegas
download unmei no roulette mawashite
point relais geant casino
the mill casino
gala bingo
craps place
old grannys playing strip
online slot machines no
book of ra online spielen kostenlos ohne anmeldung
cash bingo
download poker svenska spel se svenska spel
hard rock casino isleta new
used casino poker
new casino
poker advertising dollars companies endorsements
how much money a casino
i need money for an
island resort casino
trick 2012
california gambling
rio all suite hotel and casino
effects of gambling on
bingo grid
hollywood casino columbus minimum
money worksheets for severely
what is a wedding
best play at
blue palace resort spa
eagle pass
when to bet in
her first time for
online casino vanaf 5
best strategy to play
play money onlone
maloofs buy red rock
mgm casino washington
who owns deadwood
championship gambling
open air kino casino
new york casino
retro reels casino
good ideas for making
royal yak casino plaza las
restaurants near casino du
play cat games
game poker online untuk
10 hand blackjack tournament
coldplay casino paris 28
poker chips ebay
black hawk casino
roulette online
littlewoods poker
mikosukee indian gaming and
texas holdem hand
antigua sun
route 66 casino alb
desert diamond casino
casino bonus 100
american roulette robbie
code backgammon titanpoker
what are some problems with
fallsview casino
hotel casino carrasco
the best bingo sites
secure gambling
blackjack z4
sandia casino new years eve party
atlanta casino
inside japans puzzle palace word
game zone casino baden
age 18 and up casino
casino buses to
casino slot games how to
schecter blackjack atx c1
pictures how to play
sandals near
crown casino perth nye
restaurants in sandia
horror games to play
strip tease party poker
winning odds of
luxor casino discount
son legales los casinos online en
newcastle casino tornado
riviera hotel and casino wedding
dd tournament poker 2 5
riverwind casino
g postmessage poker smiley
diner dash 2 unlimted online
casino windsor ontario
play online games
hawaiian gardens casino
history of nevada gambling
little river casino
how to play las vegas casino
french lick casino jackpot
wild jack casino
ic money slot machines for
how can i play wms slots online u s
casino jeu gratuit
age requirement for gambling in
blackjack strategy in
sacramento bingo
poker concord
tdu2 casino vip
port canaveral gambling
online casino with paypal
vortex springs poker
play bingo and win real
red casino advert
how to choose a winning slot
firelake casino
bc gold casino
win on slot
best rated online
mini put games online
j and ts blackjack
tennessee internet
beste spel holland
roulette software
problem gambling
shreeveport casino
native american casino
maverick poker
high limit blackjack
student loan for munity college
jackpotjoy slots for
cash creek casino
how to play roulette
can i play foxy bingo on my
casino love and honor in las vegas
online poker review
grosvenor casino blackjack
international slot machine
casino poker
texas holdem odd
casino tropicana atlantic
table mountain casino black
map of lake charles
twin river casino grand
bus to philadelphia park
table window resizer
conceptual bingo
double down casino app
Home Investigations Al-Durah Reception and Consequences Impact Arab World
Contrived image

"Contrived image"
Published: Washington Post, 2005-09-21
Author: Mona Charen

ABSTRACT: Mona Charen discusses the consequences of the iconic power achieved by the image of al-Dura.

QUOTE: "Some have theorized al-Dura was accidentally killed by Palestinians and then immediately transformed into a martyr to cover up the mistake. Others believe he may have been intentionally sacrificed because his father had been a little too friendly with Israelis. We probably will never know. One thing is certain: The story of the Israeli soldiers' deliberate killing of 12-year-old Muhammad al-Dura was a damnable lie. "

KEYWORDS: al-Dura, Martyrology.

URL: Read source

The image has achieved iconic status: 12-year-old Muhammad al-Dura crouching behind a concrete barrier next to his father as (presumably) Israeli bullets ricochet around the pair. Moments later, the boy lies dead in his father's arms.

The video dates from September 2000, the start of the Second Intifada, and has become the world's favorite image of supposed Israeli brutality. France 2, the network that supplied the only footage of the shooting, reported al-Dura had "died under a hail of Israeli bullets."
Hussein Ibish, communications director of the Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Committee, declared the boy's death "one of the most damaging images in the history of Zionism." The New York Times called it "a potent new symbol of what angry Palestinians contend is their continued victimization." The Cairo street that houses the Israeli Consulate was renamed "the Boulevard of Muhammad al-Dura." A park bears his name in Morocco. Belgium put his face on a stamp.

Al-Dura's image is also spliced into the video Daniel Pearl's killers made of his beheading. As Stephanie Gutmann recounts in her outstanding new book "The Other War: Israelis, Palestinians, and the Struggle for Media Supremacy," "After Pearl makes his final statement in the confession portion -- 'my father is a Jew; my mother is a Jew; I am a Jew' -- there is a cut to Mohammed and father huddling together. Seconds before Pearl is laid on the ground and hands begin to saw at his throat with long knives, a still shot of Jamal al-Dura clasping his dying son flashes on the screen."

Every major media outlet in the world carried the al-Dura story. The narrative: Father and son wandered too close to an Israeli outpost protecting the village of Netzarim. When Israeli soldiers fired upon the pair, the father, Jamal al-Dura, waved to show they were innocent civilians. They were "answered," as put it, "with a fusillade of bullets."

When every major news organization in the world reports a story, it would be fair to assume many reporters observed this event. In fact, as Miss Gutmann and Nidra Poller in Commentary both document, every single reporter relied on the same snippet of tape provided by France 2, though many shamefully phrased their reports as if they were eyewitnesses.

Cameraman Talal Abu Rahmeh, a Palestinian stringer for a number of news agencies, testified that after a 5-minute exchange of gunfire between Palestinian police and Israelis, the Israelis fired on the unarmed father and child for 45 minutes.

Only much later, after the story had blanketed the globe and become a recruiting tool for suicide bombers in many countries, did questions about the narrative begin trickling out. The Israel Defense Forces performed a series of re-creations of the scene (after initially acknowledging its soldiers might have accidentally shot the pair) and concluded the father and son simply could not have been hit from the Israeli position.

No autopsy was performed on the boy's body. No bullets were ever retrieved. But other investigators have noted that the size and shape of the bullet holes on the concrete wall behind the pair were inconsistent with M-16s the Israelis used.

As both Miss Gutmann and Miss Poller document, the camera crews had set up at Netzarim in the morning before a single shot was fired. Why? Miss Poller has viewed all the footage she could obtain from the other news organizations at Netzarim that day and discovered that, in addition to actual scenes, the cameras also captured a number of vignettes in which "Palestinian stringers sporting prestigious logos on their vests and cameras are seen filming battle scenes staged behind the abandoned factory, well out of range of Israeli gunfire."

When Esther Schapira, a German documentary filmmaker, asked France 2 to permit her to view the entire day's film from Netzarim, not the just the 51 seconds that had so electrified the world, she was rebuffed.

Some have theorized al-Dura was accidentally killed by Palestinians and then immediately transformed into a martyr to cover up the mistake. Others believe he may have been intentionally sacrificed because his father had been a little too friendly with Israelis. We probably will never know.

One thing is certain: The story of the Israeli soldiers' deliberate killing of 12-year-old Muhammad al-Dura was a damnable lie.

Mona Charen is a nationally syndicated columnist

Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters








Facebook MySpace Twitter Digg Google Bookmarks